Skip to the content

The validation record

Kröger Example 9.2.2

The horizontal array under a 6 m/s crosswind

Tier T: a textbook worked example - a published answer, not a measurement.

System: Indirect dry cooling, natural draft, horizontal array

What was compared
The water inlet and outlet temperatures, the air mass flow rate and the mixed air outlet temperature of the indirect natural-draft tower of Example 9.2.1, a horizontal array filling a 78.3 m inlet, under a 6 m/s wind at 10 m with the heat transfer rate held at 354.39 MW.
Against
Kröger's worked Example 9.2.2 (Kröger, Vol. 2, Section 9.2), a published calculation with Du Preez's pressure coefficients and the heat transfer correction for wind, and not a measurement.
The agreement
The water inlet temperature is reproduced to within 0.11 K (+0.033%), the water and mixed air outlet temperatures to within 0.035%, and the air mass flow rate to within 0.26%. The intermediate values Cpi, Cpo, αQ and the wind speed at the tower outlet agree with the example to the digits printed.
What it shows
The agreement verifies that Kröger's crosswind method is implemented as published, on the arrangement it was fitted for: horizontal bundles filling the inlet. It does not establish the method's accuracy, and it says nothing about a vertical ring of deltas.
Source
Kröger, D.G., Air-Cooled Heat Exchangers and Cooling Towers: Thermal-Flow Performance Evaluation and Design (PennWell, 2004)Vol. 2, Example 9.2.2 (Eqs. 9.2.4-9.2.11 on the tower of Example 9.2.1)